Agenda item

Appeal Decisions (Agenda Item 11)

APP/F2605/A/13/2203676: WEETING: Prospect Lodge, Fengate Drove: Appeal against a refusal to grant planning permission for development of land without complying with a condition by Mr. R. Betts

Reference: 3PL/2012/1026/F

Decision: Appeal dismissed

Summary: The Inspector considered that to vary the condition to allow occupation of the mobile home by the appellant's daughter and her dependants would be tantamount to allowing a new dwelling in the countryside.  There is no essential need for the mobile home to become a permanent dwelling.

 

APP/F2605/A/13/2201259: NARBOROUGH: Beehive Fields, A47: Appeal against refusal of planning permission for the erection of a pig fattening unit by Mr. C. Durrance

Reference: 3PL/2013/0301/F

Decision:  Appeal dismissed

Summary: The Inspector considered that the building would have an adverse effect on the character and appearance of the Brecks Landscape Character Area.

 

APP/F2605/C/13/2194302: ATTLEBOROUGH:  Land known as Fieldview, Leys Lane: Appeal against an enforcement notice: Breach of planning control: Material change of use of land from use for garden curtilage of the property known as Ten Oaks to use for stationing and occupation of a residential mobile home on the land by Mr. G. Hamer.

Reference: ENF/2012/0414/CAS

Decision:  Appeal A by Mr. Hamer succeeds and planning permission is granted for a material change of use of the land to a mixed use of the stationing and occupation of a residential mobile home and the use of a building for motor repairs, salvage and sales on land known as Fieldview, Leys Lane, Attleborough subject to conditions .

Summary:  The Inspector considered that the development is sustainable, it is not harmful to the character and appearance of the surrounding area and that dismissal of the appeals would have a disproportionate effect with regard to human rights

APP/F2605/C/13/2194304: ATTLEBOROUGH:  Land known as Fieldview, Leys Lane:

Decision: Appeal B by Mrs. Hamer is dismissed. 

Summary: The Inspector considered that a material change of use to a mixed use which includes the stationing of a mobile home has occurred and continuous use during the ten years prior to service of the enforcement notice has not been shown.

 

APP/F2605/A/13/220131: ATTLEBOROUGH: Fieldview, Leys Lane: Appeal against a refusal to grant planning permission for retention of a mobile home for residential purposes on part of lawful commercial site by Mr. G. Hamer and Mrs. M. Hamer

Reference: 3PL/2013/0209/F

Decision:  Appeal succeeds and planning permission is granted for a material change of use of the land to a mixed use for the stationing and occupation of a residential mobile home and the use of a building for motor repairs, salvage and sales on land known as Fieldview, Leys Lane subject to conditions.

Summary:  The Inspector considered that the development is sustainable, it is not harmful to the character and appearance of the surrounding area and that dismissal of the appeals would have a disproportionate effect with regard to human rights

 

APP/F2605/A/13/2195164 and APP/F/2605/A/13/2195207: OLD BUCKENHAM: Roughlands, Grove Road: Appeal against grants of planning permission subject to conditions in respect of use being restricted to occupants of Roughland Farm by Mr. & Mrs. Richards

References: 3PL/2012/0658 (Appeal A) and 3PL/2012/0614/F (Appeal B)

Decisions: Appeal dismissed

Summary: The Inspector considered that use beyond that in accordance with the conditions would result in significant increase in traffic using Grove Road where width and restricted forward visibility are hazards to safety and free flow of traffic. The risk to highway safety should weigh substantially against removing or varying the conditons.  The extended use would not have a materially adverse effect on amenity or impact on the landscape.  The use of facilities by friends and relatives could result in levels of activity similar to a commercial undertaking.

 

APP/F2605/A/13/2205007: ATTLEBOROUGH:  Land rear of 1 Albermarle Terrace: Appeal against refusal of planning permission for the erection of a detached bungalow with garage by Mr. D. Aldous

Reference:  3PL/2013/0141/F

Decision: Appeal dismissed

Summary: The Inspector considered that whilst the scheme would be in keeping with the area and would not impact on residential amenity, the lack of a duly executed unilateral undertaking is a fundamental flaw in the proposal.

 

APP/F2605/A/13/2201606: RIDDLESWORTH:  Stud Farm: Appeal against refusal of planning permission for the change of use of land for the siting of a temporary agricultural dwelling (mobile home) by Mr. & Mrs. R.W. Evans

Reference: 3PL/2013/0472/F

Decision: Appeal allowed and planning permission granted subject to conditions

Summary: The Inspector considered that, based on the number of livestock currently and proposed to be kept on the holding, the business requires a full time employee to be permanently located on the holding

 

APP/F2605/A/13/2203554: HOE: Woodgate House, Gorgate Road: Appeal against refusal of planning permission for a new build house and separation of existing garden to form a site for the house by Mr. Martyn

Reference: 3PL/2012/1293/F

Decision:  Appeal dismissed

Summary:  The Inspector considered that the proposal would be poorly related to services and facilities, in an area where occupiers would rely on private vehicles.

Minutes:

Noted.